Festive Greetings from This Is Not Happening and welcome to our year-end, 2025 wrap-up episode. As always we split the pod into Part 1 and Part 2.Part 1 features our Top 10 favourite albums of 2025. We use a proprietary algorithm to create our list our collective favourite albums, we're talking nascent data-science excellence! Every year it throws up some surprises as our tastes are so different (and in some ways so similar.Part 2 features a festive Spin It or Bin It. We each bring a candidate for track of the year and ask the age old question 'Spin It or Bin It' … will anyone really bin anyone elses Track of the Year? Probably.To retain the tension, I won't share any spoilers here … other than to share a 40 track playlist of some of our favourite 2025 tracks … here.Whatever you do at this time of year, who ever you do it with … have a good one.Please join us in January where we will go back to the usual format of Album of the Month + Spin It or Bin It.We've been writing the blog for years come and have a look – https://thisisnothappening.net/
Another month, another pod. A very warm and most welcome to Episode 51 of This is Not Happening (TINH), an Album of the Month (AOTM) Podcast. In Part 1 we deep dive into an Album that one of us has chosen and in Part 2 we play ‘Spin it or Bin it’. This is where we pick a theme and each select a song that represents that theme. We judge each others selections by asking the question ‘Spin It or Bin It’?
This month, in Part 1, Joey sits in the middle of a ‘divisive discussion’ focused on Caribou’s new album Honey. One of us think it’s some of the best of Caribou’s work, one of us thinks it’s much less than that.
In Part 2, Spin It or Bin It, our theme this month is ‘Basslines’, for once we stipulated no other rules.
Part 1 | Caribou | ‘Honey’
We all love Caribou. There are few artists that sit in the centre of the TINH venn diagram, but Caribou is one of them. However, we all have different favourite Caribou albums and therefore have different expectations and hopes when it comes to a new Caribou album.
The debate is fierce. We cover many topics including how to be fair when an artist produces something we weren’t expecting, can you remove the bias of your disappointment and critique the album without bias? Unfortunately, we also end up talking about AI and music too.
Watch this short of Dan talking about ‘Volume’ … HERE
BBC Sounds interview with Dan Snaith from this month … HERE
Part 2 | Spin It or Bin It | ‘Basslines’
The best Spin It or Bin It’s are often the simplest. This month, the theme is one word and no extra rules or exclusions, ‘Basslines’. However you want to interpret it, it’s cool.N
Festive Greetings from This Is Not Happening and welcome to our year-end, 2025 wrap-up episode. As always we split the pod into Part 1 and Part 2.Part 1 features our Top 10 favourite albums of 2025. We use a proprietary algorithm to create our list our collective favourite albums, we're talking nascent data-science excellence! Every year it throws up some surprises as our tastes are so different (and in some ways so similar.Part 2 features a festive Spin It or Bin It. We each bring a candidate for track of the year and ask the age old question 'Spin It or Bin It' … will anyone really bin anyone elses Track of the Year? Probably.To retain the tension, I won't share any spoilers here … other than to share a 40 track playlist of some of our favourite 2025 tracks … here.Whatever you do at this time of year, who ever you do it with … have a good one.Please join us in January where we will go back to the usual format of Album of the Month + Spin It or Bin It.We've been writing the blog for years come and have a look – https://thisisnothappening.net/
We’ve hit the BIG 5-0 and we’re still speaking to each other. It’s delgight to welcome to Episode 50 of This is Not Happening (TINH). An Album of the Month (AOTM) Podcast where in Part 1 we deep dive into an Album that one of us has chosen and in Part 2 we play ‘Spin it or Bin it’. This is where we pick a theme and each select a song that represents that theme. We judge each others selections by asking the question ‘Spin It or Bin It’?
This month, in Part 1, David introduces the latest album from one of my favourite obsession artists, ‘My Method Actor’ by Nilifur Yanya.
In Part 2, Spin It or Bin It, we return for our quarterly visit to the theme of ‘New Music’ … anything released since August 1st.
Part 1 | Nilifur Yanya | My Method Actor
This is the third full length studio album from Yanya. She is a super interesting artist blending soul, jazz, indie and a bunch of other sounds and influences in there. This album is something of a departure for her following her last 2 albums that perhaps embraced the indie side of her influences. This album is a super smart melding of all of her influences, definitely leaning more towards the soul and jazz side of her music. It feels like a return to some of her earliest EP releases and I love it for that fact.
I feel like I drew the short straw here. We have an artist that we all love and they have a new album out, easy right? Slam dunk. Everyone’s happy and we all have a 60 minute love-in on the pod about how amazing Dan Snaith (aka Caribou, aka Manitou, aka Daphni) is …
… wrong.
Dan goes and throws a curve ball (in some peoples opinion, in others, he follows an evolutionary path that he set out three albums ago) and release an album that I would argue not many people expected. I think a quick Caribou re-cap is in order;
Dan Snaith, Canadian dude who makes music and aligns these with 3 identities … but to keep this simple we’ll focus on 2 if thats ok?
Caribou is the identity that he tends to release hyper intelligent, elevated pop music with an electronic leaning (but TBF indulges many genres and sub-genres across it’s 6 albums). Caribou has traditionally been music for the headphones, the bedroom, the soul.
Daphni is where Dan embraces the elecronic more and specifically embraces the dancefloor, this has traditionally music for the club.
We all love Caribou.
We have different favourite Caribou albums.
This is important as I think what we expect or want from Caribou has a significant impact on our relationship with Honey.
Honey is Caribou’s 6th album. And it is different. But every Caribou album is pretty different. Andorra is 60’s Pysch Pop reinvented for the latter half of the naughties. Swim is my favourite Caribou album and is entirely different from Andorra in every way save for it’s inherent ‘Caribouness’. Anyone, any music fan especially, would be able to at least notice, if not describe the similarities between Andorra and Swim despite it’s significant differences. I resonated so strongly with Swim that I was almost in tears when Our Love was released. I was so disappointed. It literally took me years to come to terms with the album. I love it now. I don’t play it that often but I grew to love it and now recognise it’s inherent ‘Caribouness’ but I had a BIG, negative emotional response to it. I had a ‘mini-tanti’ as Hugh Grant calls it (basically he had a melt down on live US TV) … I had mine in Urmston, Trafford. ‘Suddenly’ was very much in line with ‘Our Love’ and was no surprise. It had ‘inherent Caribouness’ and followed a line from Our Love but was also a massive departure from Andorra in one direction and Swim from another.
Honey is another massive departure. It is 12 short tracks of very electronic music. They feel in one way, more Daphni than Caribou in that they feel more club focused … but they’re also all 3 min pop songs (more Caribou leaning?). There is pop brilliance and shine and it feels like it’s made for the radio as much as the club. I am not sure what radio but the tracks follow pop rules more than they follow dance floor rules (discuss)?
So, Dan is embracing the club. But he’s retaining the pop? For me, the album as a whole features much ‘inherent Caribouness’ but this is unevenly distributed across the tracks. With some feeling much less inherently Caribou, and in some people’s opinions, not Caribou at all.
We’ve already, mostly drawn our lines of battle.
On one side …
This is a great album.
If it was made by anyone else we’d be saying, it’s great, it makes me feel fucking old but it’s great.
It is inherently Caribou, you just have to work for that a little more than other albums.
On the other side …
… Well, some pretty uncomplimentary things.
‘this is not for me’ vibes
Not a Caribou album.
‘Like being attacked by toddlers with Protools’
I get both sides but align with the former.
Let’s touch briefly on AI cause it feels like I have to. Dan uses AI tools to alter his voice. This is freaking some people out. It isn’t freaking me out. I don’t care. Musicians have been altering their voices for as long as they could, with what ever tools they had access too. For me this is a distraction. I don’t care. But I also get that some feel very strongly about this so we will defo discuss it at some length on the blog. My side of that conversation will be short … unless I get drawn into it.
I thought it would be The Power Ballad Themed ‘Spin It or Bin It’ that might divide us … but it appears that it is one of our favourite artists (and AI) that might do that! I am half dreading, half looking forward to the chat on the pod.
There was a moment when I watching Nilufer Yanya last week at the Brudenell in Leeds, when I was hit by a strong question – what am I watching? What is this music? Yanya has been doing a few in-store stripped back sets promoting her third album, My Method Actor, which dropped last Friday.
She had been expecting that the Leeds date, like the others, were a genuine in-store in a record store or similar – and seemed a bit bemused and slightly wrong-footed to start to realise it felt more like a proper gig. She had no drummer, with only two (very adept) musicians with her, one on sax and keys, the other on bass/guitar. I was expecting, as a result, to find the songs I already knew – four or five of them had already been slipping out the last few months – to feel a little underpowered. How wrong I was. If anything, they revealed themselves even more clearly – Yanya’s gosssamer light, murmured, throaty vocal hung in the air with surprising power, and the knotty construction of her clever, brilliant songs seemed so logical when you hear them live. But I was still nagging away at that question: what is this? Girl with guitar and vocals, quite angsty lyrics. Indie guitar music right? Not really. There’s a proggy-ness to the way she plays guitar at times, and her chord structures are angular and surprising in a way that feels more like jazz than pop music. Let’s throw post-rock into the mix too just for fun.She clearly plays with different tunings for different songs and was having to retune her guitar in between (she started to relax and displayed a lovely goofiness with her interactions with the audience that were wonderfully at odds with the intensity of her performance). I still don’t know what this is. Of course, in the post-Spotify era, why should this matter? Every artist is a jukebox of influences. But I think I want to know why because I want to understand why this is such a special album – because let’s be clear, I am completely blown away by this extraordinary record.
Nilufer Yanya burst onto the scene in 2019 with her much-lauded debut album Miss Universe. She seemed to arrive fully formed, comfortably living in a sound that seemed part confessional angular indie of early PJ Harvey, and part something less easy to categorise. I liked her immediately, though I found her follow-up Painless not quite as powerful and it didn’t quite stay with me.
Maybe it’s easy to say this when an artist finally delivers the perfect record in your own musical wheelhouse, but though I’ve really tracks of hers in the past, I’ve always had the feeling that her albums can feel a bit disjointed, and I like some tracks more than others. So when she released the first single from this album early this year, the astonishing Like I Say (I Runaway), I was pretty excited. It was, as they say, an absolute banger, and right now, I think it’s going to be my song of the year.
Every song that’s followed this one has been just as intriguing, and crucially, they’ve all felt part of a maturing and a broadening of Yanya’s sound. But nothing prepared me for what those songs would sound like in the context of a whole album. Even the songs I’ve smashed to death like Like I Say and My Method Actor sound fresh and new when you hear the sequencing of this record. And let’s talk about the sequencing. Is there a better opener than Keep on Dancing this year – crisp, taut, desperate, urgent – all the things this album is about, finding yourself in your late 20s, broken relationships, fears about yourself, about how you present yourself (hence Method Actor). Then onto Like I Say which now sounds like the things it was born to do – to take you into the album as a whole. To follow that with Method Actor feels almost rude – the disgustingly fantastic guitar on that song should be against the law.
You’d think the album might be front loading the goodies, and I did worry a little on first listens that the second half was a more languid, slow-burn affair. But as each song opens itself on repeated listens, it starts to dawn on you – or it did on me anyway – that there isn’t. bad moment on this tight, brilliant 11 songs, 44 minute masterpiece. I could go on about individual tracks, but we can do that on the pod. But I have to say that the Robert Fripp prog drone guitar on Call It Love almost makes me scream with joy every time I hear it!
Shout to Yanya’s collaborator Wilma Archer, about whom I know little – but he has clearly found a way to showcase Yanya’s brilliance to full effect, and Yanya has been very effusive about his role in the record. His background in electronic music is the key to this I think – there is openness and a simplicity about the songs’ arrangements that allow the songwriting and Yanya’s lovely vocals to shine. You hear every instrument, every line. It’s a triumph.
So yeah, I’m a fan. It’s in my top 3 for the year. It might even take the top spot. I might, in fact, need to take a break soon because I can’t get enough of it. How about you, brothers…?
Festive Greetings from This Is Not Happening and welcome to our year-end, 2025 wrap-up episode. As always we split the pod into Part 1 and Part 2.Part 1 features our Top 10 favourite albums of 2025. We use a proprietary algorithm to create our list our collective favourite albums, we're talking nascent data-science excellence! Every year it throws up some surprises as our tastes are so different (and in some ways so similar.Part 2 features a festive Spin It or Bin It. We each bring a candidate for track of the year and ask the age old question 'Spin It or Bin It' … will anyone really bin anyone elses Track of the Year? Probably.To retain the tension, I won't share any spoilers here … other than to share a 40 track playlist of some of our favourite 2025 tracks … here.Whatever you do at this time of year, who ever you do it with … have a good one.Please join us in January where we will go back to the usual format of Album of the Month + Spin It or Bin It.We've been writing the blog for years come and have a look – https://thisisnothappening.net/
Welcome to Episode 49 of This is Not Happening (TINH). An Album of the Month (AOTM) Podcast where in Part 1 we deep dive into an Album that one of us has chosen and in Part 2 we play ‘Spin it or Bin it’. This is where we pick a theme and each select a song that represents that theme. We judge each others selections by asking the question ‘Spin It or Bin It’?
This month, in Part 1, Nolan goes back to his spiritual home, Hip Hop and has picked an album that the genre has been waiting decades for – Common and Pete Rock, The Auditorium Vol. 1.
In Part 2, Spin It or Bin It, the theme sounds simple but it turned out to be deceptively divisive. This month we delve into ‘Power Ballads’ … but what actually is a Power Ballad?
Part 1 | Common & Pete Rock | The Auditorium Vol. 1
If you’re age (old AF) and you like Hip Hop then you’ve probably been listening to these two legends for 30 odd years. Common is 52, Mr. Rock is 54. They’ve been at the top of their games for decades but does the combination deliver synergy or something a little less?
So what is a Power Ballad? We all know the classics, but if we try and bring something a little different then first we have to have some sort of definition. We’ve picked 4 tracks that aren’t on many Power Ballad playlists …
Festive Greetings from This Is Not Happening and welcome to our year-end, 2025 wrap-up episode. As always we split the pod into Part 1 and Part 2.Part 1 features our Top 10 favourite albums of 2025. We use a proprietary algorithm to create our list our collective favourite albums, we're talking nascent data-science excellence! Every year it throws up some surprises as our tastes are so different (and in some ways so similar.Part 2 features a festive Spin It or Bin It. We each bring a candidate for track of the year and ask the age old question 'Spin It or Bin It' … will anyone really bin anyone elses Track of the Year? Probably.To retain the tension, I won't share any spoilers here … other than to share a 40 track playlist of some of our favourite 2025 tracks … here.Whatever you do at this time of year, who ever you do it with … have a good one.Please join us in January where we will go back to the usual format of Album of the Month + Spin It or Bin It.We've been writing the blog for years come and have a look – https://thisisnothappening.net/
Welcome to Episode 48 of This is Not Happening (TINH). An Album of the Month (AOTM) Podcast where in Part 1 we deep dive into an Album that one of us has chosen and in Part 2 we play ‘Spin it or Bin it’. This is where we pick a theme and each select a song that represents that theme. We judge each others selections by asking the question ‘Spin It or Bin It’?
This month, in Part 1, Guy has picked the an album that could not be further from last month’s Charli XCX outing. He’s also picked the best named TINH AOTM ever, Linda Thompson’s Proxy Music.
In Part 2, Spin It or Bin It, the theme is simple … ‘Long Songs’ no explanation of the theme required here apart from Guy’s completely arbitrary suggestion that all tracks had to be over 8 minutes.
Part 1 | Linda Thompson | Proxy Music
English Folk musician legend Linda Thompson has lived enough life for several people. The good, the bad and everything in between. She’s now a 72 year old songwriter force who has sadly lost her super-power to sing … so she’s written songs for other artists to perform. The album is an eclectic collection of songs and collaborators pulled together through the concept of performing through a proxy. The critics love it with a combined Metacritic Score of 86. There’s a lot of love on the pod but not without a few reservations along the way.
Watch Linda on Jools Holland back in 2011 videos here.
Guy references a couple of articles in his introduction and conversation they’re worth a look and can be found here and here.
Part 2 | Spin It or Bin It | Long Songs.
We love a long song. Even our resident (but absent on this episode) pop being loves a long song. Guy defines a long song as anything over 8 mins, who are we to argue with that kind of logic. So them’s the rules. Who bought what to the table to judge in Spin It or Bin It?
This month we’re delving into Common and Pete Rock’s The Auditorium Vol. 1. There have been times throughout history that the human race didn’t know how much we actually needed certain super combinations (individually doing well on their own, but even better with the perfect match). Salt & pepper, fish & chips, milk & cookies, David & striped t-shirts.
Much like the aforementioned, both Pete Rock and Common have had long heralded music careers spanning over 30 years which individually are eye watering. Both have had multi generational successes in the underground and mainstream. From Pete Rock’s historic track T.R.O.Y. (They Reminisce Over You), production with Nas on Illmatic, Run DMC, House of Pain, and Kendrick Lemar there is a constant Pete Rock essence throughout music culture constantly. Common has released 15 albums to date. A mainstay within the (new) native tongues, Common has been a long time collaborator with the likes of De La Soul, Tribe Called Quest, Talib Kweli, Black thought, etc. whilst also maintaining muse stature of some of the best producers in hip hop; No ID, J Dilla, Kanye and of course Pete Rock. You can add three Grammy Awards, and Academy Award a Primetime Emmy Awards and Golden Globe Award to his achievements (did I mention he is also a pretty good actor?)…..Whilst writing this I wonder to myself if these two need any introductions at all?
Not resting on their laurels, they continue a steady output of creativity within hip hop and beyond. If you want some insight to the history of both Common and Pete Rock and their respective parts within hip hop’s story I encourage you to listen to them on Drink Champs (though you’ll need a spare 4 hours), it’s not only entertaining but mind blowing how involved they are within the cultures history. One key thing that shines through in the interview is not only each artist’s deep history within hip hop, but their love of the music and the culture. This is evident throughout The Auditorium Vol. 1.
As you can imagine, there was a lot of buzz in the build up to the albums’ release. Since world of the album broke in late 2023, expectations were high for the project being released from two of hip hop’s most respected sons. Drenched with inspiration from the golden era of hip hop (the 90’s), the album delivers arguably some of the best music both artists have released their heralded careers. Differing from recent hip hop albums we have discussed, this offering isn’t as dense. Pete Rock’s well-orchestrated laid back beats compliment Common’s welcoming narrative flow.
From the get go, all that is good in hip hop shines through on the lead track Dreamin.
There is a lovely sprinkling of soul throughout the album. Tracks like This Man, Fortunate and Now and Then not only compliments Common’s laid back story telling —-(flow)— but also highlights Pete Rock’s sample prose and highlights why he has been long heralded as one of the best beat makers in hip hop for both his production and ear to match the perfect beat with the MC he’s working with. Not forgetting their roots, they delve into the boom bap on tracks like Wise Up, Chi-Town and Stellar, reminding that a strong sample and well executed scratching can be all you need for the perfect hip hop track matched with one of Hip Hop’s most consistent MC’s is a wonderful thing.
A smorgasbord of exception tracks, the stand out for me is All Kind Of Ideas. Sliding in with its subtle bass line and clinical scratch of Rakim’s ‘all kinda ideas’, we’re welcomed by a rare 18 bars from Pete Rock ‘I’m soul brother uno, black from the future. Make beats on the table if I break my computer and still make hits like I used to. Keep your top five, I’m god’s favourite producer’. One for the hip hop heads, the song instantly puts a smile on my face.
Pete Rock & CL Smooth’s T.R.O.Y. is one of my favourite songs of all time, and Common’s Resurrection is one of my favourite albums of all time. There was a high bar for this album in my mind. Has it been met, yes and more. The Auditorium Vol. 1 is super accessible. It’s the kind of album that people that ‘sort’ of like hip hop will love whilst giving everything you want out of a positive conscious hip hop album. Common’s positive lyrics and Pete Rocks refreshing beats have served up an album that is a ray of light. I’m still early into this album, but it’s already one of the stand outs for 2024 for me.
Linda Thompson / Kami Thompson – Solitary Traveller
Something odd is happening. Over the past few years, I’ve started to really like folk music. I suspect I’ve always liked some of it – think Laura Marling for modern artists, but far less from the golden 60s and 70s eras – but just not realised. Much more so than me liking country, though it also turns out I quite like things that are a little bit country, though more western than country. But I digress.
I wasn’t intending on a folk album this month. I’m not sure what I was intending. But the music release calendar doesn’t always match up how you like. There were a slew of brilliant albums up to May, then a barren spell before a brewing cavalry charge in the late summer. And having leant hard on securing a spot for my beloved Yard Act in March, things didn’t quite fall as I’d planned. Everything Everything’s Mountainhead, one of my Top 10 albums of the year, nailed on, was out simply too long ago. Another love of mine, the mighty Crowded House, back from their 90s heyday with unexpected new record, Gravity Stairs, proved a little too niche to my surprise and slight sadness. But then the themes of that album’s treatise on ageing, family and music’s place in the universe, turned out to lead me to the one I picked this month: British Folk legend Linda Thompson’s intriguing new album, Proxy Music.
Unlike Joey’s picking of Charli xcx’s Brat last month, I had listened to this album a number of times in my scrap to find something that would fit my interest but also give us enough mileage for a podcast episode. I can’t think of a more contrasting record to follow it up, but in some ways this is very much befitting that slot. Because it’s an album that shares a similar intention of putting your true self to music, even if the artist, genre and style are as different as heavy metal and Chicago house. However, as I dealt with the disappointment of Crowded House failing the pod test, the more I listened to this record, the more it crept up on me and felt a better and better fit.
Linda Thompson’s backstory alone is fascinating enough. You can read about it in many places, so I won’t regurgitate it line by line, but she made her name on the late-60s London folk scene, joined folk supergroup ‘The Bunch’, whose members included former Fairpoirt Convention alumni, including her future husband and musical collaborator, Richard Thompson. This led to recording with Fairport Convention, then, following their marriage in 1972, releasing a number of acclaimed albums with Richard across the first half of that decade. Richard distracted with dabbling in Sufism, came back to release a trio of further albums, for which the final one, Shoot Out The Lights, found success in the US, and sparked a tour in 1982. Having separated before they embarked on it, the tour saw the couple fall out in public, past the end of their own tethers, and the end of their musical relationship for two decades.
Linda was first hit around this time by the condition spasmodic dysphonia, which affected her speech and singing voice. While some solo work was released in the mid-80s, she wasn’t to record again until the 2000s, when temporary treatment allowed her to perform and record into the next decade, including musical reunions with Richard Thompson, and also recording with her children, particularly Teddy and Kami Thompson, and finally on the album Family, a work created and produced by Teddy, and featuring a number of the extended Thompson clan. This was to be her final vocal work before her condition meant a reappraisal of how she would have to make music.
So the release of Proxy Music was unexpected, because what is expected of a woman with no voice to sing any more? But having continued to write well into her 70s, the album’s existence allows us to see another late-stage chapter in Thompson’s storied career, and we are all better off for it. Recruiting not just family Kami, Teddy and even Richard again, the album – a wry riff on Roxy Music’s debut down to the brilliantly off-kilter reimagining of its cover with a rictus grinner Linda on the cover – reaches further out into her extended world of friends, fans and musical connections, with both Martha and Rufus Wainwright, John Grant, The Proclaimers and Ren Harvieu, with different generations of artists from the UK . and US. But because this is new music, it cunningly shifts away from the tired genre of covers albums. This is new, and feels it.
While impressive-sounding on paper, it would’ve been easy for the album to be disjointed and elegiacal. Given the freshness of its songs and their ability to partner so well with their performers, at the hands of Teddy Thompson as producer, what results is an winding collection of absorbing and beautiful songs that criss-cross through Thompson’s life and leave us with the impression of an artist we all should have known more than we do, and a life lived to its full extent, both success and failure, joy and tragedy. It’s another example of an album that finds you more than you find it, a slice of internet-driven happenstance that I could’ve pictured David reviewing much more easily than I (Thompson, after all, once had a dalliance with Davide’s folk icon Nick Drake).
And from the opening bars of The Solitary Traveller, it grabs you, Kami Thompson’s wistful harmonies flipping the tales of love and loss back on its heels as you realise the solitude of her mother’s tale hasn’t left her alone and unhappy, but the opposite. It’s a picture of a determined, strong woman looking back on her life with fondness and pride, and not ennui. ‘Lonely life / where is thy sting? /lonely life, there’s no such thing’. Her younger life may have been darkened by misogyny but she’s celebrating her hard-won freedom as her years advance. It also sets the scene of a record that doesn’t shy away from heartbreak and sadness – and riffs on its place in the folk canon – but willingly looks at life in all its glory and bleakness, as if one cannot exist without the other.
The songs roll through at speed and full of vibrancy, from the simplicity of piano of Martha Wainwright’s rueful vocals on Or Nothing At All, ‘there’s the future, here’s the past / another dream that couldn’t last in love’s economy’. The Proclaimer’s emotional delivery on Bonnie Lass is a surprising delight, singing of dreams and the past, and Rufus Wainwright’s smoky jazz-influencedwork on Darling This Will Never Do, perhaps the only moment that feels a bit out of step with the rest of the album’s folk (but perhaps that’s just me). Thompson’s desire to go back to the pre-rock’n’roll era of the ‘pop’ of her parents was behind that song, and who are we to suggest that’s out of step on an album concocted from her eight decades on this planet?
There are many highlights: the biggest – for me – is the meta John Grant,sung by the man himself, about Linda’s love for his own work. In the hands of others less able to align themselves with that knowing nod of the story and attach their rich vocals to it, it could come off as overly ironic, but it’s a truly wonderful song that Grant himself has fully invested himself in. Mudlark, performed by The Rails (Thompson’s daughter Kami and her husband Pretenders and Pogues guitarist James Walbourne) is a slice of early morning acoustic beauty, that seems to blow cobwebs away for me, and Shores Of America is delivered perfectly by Virginian Dori Freeman, full of Thompson’s wit from the (perhaps autobiographical) tale of a woman leaving her man behind: “And if it’s true/That only the good die young/Lucky old you/’Cause you’ll be around until kingdom come.”
One of the albums other struggles for me was That’s The Way the Polka Goes, a song which I’ve been on a hell of a journey with. It feels as if it could be on a Decemberists album, with its stomping, clapping theatrics and lyrics, and I veer between quaint interest and the desire to skip. Three Shaky Ships could be a modern folk classic, at the hands of The Unthanks, and there’s a real poignancy about Teddy finishing off with Those Damn Roches, a treatise on the bonds of a fractured family that only mend when they are in song – ‘bound together in blood and song / who can break us? / when we are singing loud and strong / who can take us? = but can’t stand each other’s company for long when they aren’t making music: ‘faraway Thompsons tug at my heart / can’t get along except when we’re apart’. In itself, a story of a remarkable family’s history and how music forever pulls them together, five decades in.
It has really surprised me by how much I like it, and how much I find myself singing its songs, especially the opening three. This is not an album that is made for me. It’s not a story or songs that should be anywhere my wheelhouse, but this blog and podcast has frequently pushed me out of my comfort zone, and if this is the result, then I can only lean into it each time it throws up a surprise.
Festive Greetings from This Is Not Happening and welcome to our year-end, 2025 wrap-up episode. As always we split the pod into Part 1 and Part 2.Part 1 features our Top 10 favourite albums of 2025. We use a proprietary algorithm to create our list our collective favourite albums, we're talking nascent data-science excellence! Every year it throws up some surprises as our tastes are so different (and in some ways so similar.Part 2 features a festive Spin It or Bin It. We each bring a candidate for track of the year and ask the age old question 'Spin It or Bin It' … will anyone really bin anyone elses Track of the Year? Probably.To retain the tension, I won't share any spoilers here … other than to share a 40 track playlist of some of our favourite 2025 tracks … here.Whatever you do at this time of year, who ever you do it with … have a good one.Please join us in January where we will go back to the usual format of Album of the Month + Spin It or Bin It.We've been writing the blog for years come and have a look – https://thisisnothappening.net/
Welcome to Episode 47 of This is Not Happening. An Album of the Month Podcast where in Part 1 we deep dive into an Album that one of us has chosen and in Part 2 we play ‘Spin it or Bin it’. This is where we pick a theme and each select a song that represents that theme. We judge each others selections by asking the question ‘Spin It or Bin It’?
This month, in Part 1, Joey has picked the most obvious choice for 4 middle aged dads, Brat by Charli XCX. It is impossible to ignore the critical response for this album so we all dive headfirst into the first Charli album that any of us has experienced. And it’s a belter … but I am pretty sure it will also divide opinion.
In Part 2, Spin It or Bin It, the theme is simple … ‘New Music’ (tracks released since 01.05.24. However, one of us picked a 49 year old track. Take a listen to hear him justify this decision.
Part 1 | Charli XCX | Brat
With a whopping 95% score on Metacritic, this album has had a massive impact from critics right across the music press’s broad spectrum of publications. It’s 15 tracks with an average length well under 3 minutes. And it has some serious weight behind a savage combo of pure pop punches. But there is WAY WAY more to it that sugar-coated pop prettiness as we get stuck right into.
Every 3 months (or so) we pick to do ‘New Tracks’ which we define as being released 2-3 months before our podcast record date (01.05.24). We’ve got 4 interesting tracks this month. We’ve got two very different female sole artist indie tracks, one undeniable piece of piano driven, laid back housey, post-club loveliness and of course something French from David.
The general narrative of mainstream pop-mega-stars and pop-mega-stardom has changed massively since the perfect, pre-packaged, plastic pop Princes and Princesses of the ’90s and early ’00s. With the rise of the internet, the blogosphere and then social media we were given a (faux) proximity to our pop stars that we never had before. This changed our relationship with them and them with us. Instead of pop stars being portrayed as untouchable, unknowable mega-beings. They were portrayed to us as ‘just like us’ normal everyday beings that happened to be some of the best known people in the world. Likeableness and nicessness became a commodity that they traded in, regardless of its authenticity. If they are (were?) ‘just like us’ then this mirror reflection of ourselves should be a nice, likeable reflection.
Charlie XCX has just chucked a grenade into the middle of all of this shit.
We start every review of an Album of the Month with the question ‘what did you expect and what did you get?’. Never has the cover art of an AOTM helped us answer the first part of the question so much. The album cover very clearly tells you what to expect; expect luminous green, expect brash, expect brat-ishness, expect green-with-envy, expect bitchiness and expect bold, brave honesty’. You do get all of this, but I’d argue, not as unlike-ably bratish as I was expecting.
It’s impossible to ignore the critical reaction to this album. It is currently sitting as Metacritic’s no.1 ranked album of the year with a 95/100 score from 24 reviews – take a look. The first 7 reviews are 100%. I don’t think I’ve ever seen that. This is Charlie’s 6th album, the culmination of 15 years of making music and 10 years and 5 previous albums of recording music. She’s managed to create a cult, niche status and persona despite massive commercial success. Charlie’s rise to stardom started with making music in her bedroom, sharing on social media, playing at raves and parties … the club is strong in her past and her present. This is pop record for the clubs. You can feel, smell and taste the sweat on your skin if you let yourself. There’s always been something of an edge to her that seems to cut deeper than the record company’s desired facade.
So what is this album? It’s 16 tracks. It’s 41 minutes. That means the average track length is comfortably under 3 mins. The longest track is only 3 mins 23. The shortest 1 min 49. But none of them are interludes. It must be said, if you don’t like a specific track, it’s gone before you know. I genuinely wouldn’t lose a single track. And I would not change the sequence of tracks at all. There are some that resonate more than others of course, but even the most brash, the most brat-ish tracks do something for me that I really like. Yeah get scuzzy, sleazy, bleary eyed nights out but you also get anxiety, envy, self-conciousness, self-awareness and moments of pure self confidence and agency all wrapped in a perfect pop sheen.
Let’s talk about envy, many of the tracks on this album are about Charli’s status as a pop star and how this compares to her contemporary mega-stars. But there are two that stand out ‘Girl, So Confusing’ (clearly about Lorde) and ‘Sympathy is a Knife’ (clearly about old Swifty). There are a lot of emotions to talk about here. None of them are emotions that most people are proud of and far fewer willing to write songs about. In a recent podcast (listen here) she talks about this in majestic honesty and with great impact …
‘This is my favourite part of the high-art-ness of music and the low-art-ness of popstar, pop-culture, this brings the three dimensional world to songs’ i.e. it’s the real, the honest, the real-life and real-emotions of human existence that make things relatable and real. She also goes on to say ‘I don’t think you’re a bad feminist just cause you don’t see eye to eye with every woman.’
I think this album is massively strong lyrically speaking, it’s the secret sauce. She is not a poet. She is not trying to be. She’s talked about writing lyrics differently for this album, which is something I’d noticed before hearing that interview. She writes lyrics like she’s texting or updating the group chat. I chose these examples carefully as the lyrics feel like intimate messages to people close to her conveyed on digital media … but not public facing digital media. It’s personal, real and raw. Its everyday language. She references people by their first names, her fiance, her producer and friends and collaborators that she’s lost. You feel like she’s sharing, letting you in … but again, with no or minimal facade. She is self conscious and self-deprecating in a very similar way to Amy Winehouse, I find this fascinating, and if I’m honest, a little spooky. Given that I’ve never heard a Charli XCX album before this, I feel like she’s let me know her. An almost identical feeling to hearing ‘Frank’ for this first time.
Let’s end on production. This album could have been recorded WAY WAY scuzzier than it was. The songs are strong enough to carry some major imperfections. There are imperfections, perfectly placed and curated to generate maximum impact. But this a pristine, piece of pop music with the production you would expect from something that will take Charli to the next level of stardom (and is certainly doing that). So, there is plenty of auto-tune, plenty of voice modulation and filters. I’m ok with this. It’s pop music. It’s ‘hyper-pop’, it fits. When discussing Auto Tune on the Tape Notes podcast (listen here) she basically says that she swaps vocal perfection for immediacy, for ‘real’ and that she’s lazy, smokes and drinks so … you know, auto-tune. Fair play Charlie.
Love it or hate it, you’ve got admire it.
I love it. It’s taken some research, some understanding, some exploration of a world I knew very little about to come to that opinion. But this is my kind of pop music. It bangs.